Should You Demand An Atto ey During Police Questioning? Yes!
Written by James Garrett
The right to have a criminal atto ey with you in the course of any police questioning has long been a fabric of our legal society since the mid-1960s. The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in the 1966 landmark case of Miranda v. Arizona that criminal investigators are expected to advise people of their Constitutional legal rights prior to asking any questions (Miranda Rights). Among those rights is the right to have a criminal defense lawyer present during any and all questioning. Other Supreme Court decisions have licensed most every police questioning tactic, which includes lying to and deceiving the suspect. Police may intimidate you by the threat of arrest, lie to you relating to their knowledge of the facts, lie to you about an eyewitness who has identified you, and let you know they will work with the prosecutor to help you out. With that knowledge of police interrogation ethics, is it any wonder why you should demand a lawyer during the process? If not, you are choosing to enter a combat with no armor and no weapon. Most individuals are not familiar with these "rules of the game" when approached by police. Many may not even realize they are really being setup to be a suspect. What might seem like a friendly, casual law enforcement encounter can quickly change to a scenario with you in cuffs with a free ride to the city jail. It is essential that you choose to protect yourself from misinterpretations, misrepresentations, and misinformation. A competent criminal defense atto ey will be ready to spot these typical law enforcement techniques. He will then be able to present you with reliable advice as to what questions to answer, and when to say enough is enough. Believe me when I tell you that police investigators will say nearly anything and make you feel as uncomfortable as possible to get you to speak to them quickly, before you have had the opportunity to seek legal advice. You should decline any comments conce ing a criminal matter, whether you've got anything at all to do with it or not. Too many charges have been brought against clients due to misinterpretations of statements. Remember the scene from My Cousin Vinny in which Ralph Macchio is repeating back the question to the sheriff, "I shot the clerk". To him, he was shocked by the question; in trial it was used against him as a declaration of admission. This is not unusual in criminal law. The magic words that conclude all law enforcement questioning are, "I want to speak to an atto ey." Protect yourself, your reputation along with your freedom. At all times demand a criminal atto ey for all law enforcement interrogation.
Atto ey James Garrett is the founding member of Garrett Law Group, PLC in Virginia Beach, VA. If you are in need of a Virginia Beach criminal lawyer, please contact him at (757) 422-4646. Please visit our firm's blog for more information on Virginia criminal defense law.
Article author
About the Author
Further reading
Further Reading
Article
What Canada's 2026 PGP Pause Means for Families Planning Reunification
This article explains what Canada's 2026 pause on new Parents and Grandparents Program applications means for families hoping to reunite with parents or grandparents. It discusses the Super Visa as an alternative and highlights practical steps families can take while waiting for future PGP updates.
August 10, 2026
Article
Is the Clover Credit Card Terminal Worth It for Small Businesses?
Running a small business today comes with a lot of challenges, and one of the biggest is handling payments efficiently. Customers expect fast, easy, and secure payment options, whether they are paying in-store, online, or on the go. If your business struggles with slow payment systems or outdated terminals, it can affect both sales and customer satisfaction. This is why choosing the right credit card terminal is so important. A good system not only processes payments but also
January 16, 2026
Article
DIY Car Interior Detailing Tips to Remove Stains and Odors
Keeping your car interior clean is more than just about appearance. A clean car makes driving more enjoyable, reduces allergens, and even helps protect the materials inside your vehicle. Over time, dirt, crumbs, spills, and dust can build up, making your car look worn and even causing bad odors. Whether you eat in your car, transport pets, or drive in dusty areas, your interior can easily become messy without regular care. While professional detailing is always an option, it
January 9, 2026
Article
Smart Door Lock vs Traditional Door Lock: Which Is More Secure?
Home security is something no homeowner can afford to ignore. Your door lock is the first line of defense against unwanted entry, and choosing the right type of lock can make a big difference in how safe your home feels. For many years, traditional door locks have been the standard choice. They are familiar, simple, and widely used in homes around the world. However, technology has changed the way we protect our homes. Smart door locks are now becoming more popular, especiall
January 6, 2026