Telling a Child What to Do and How to Behave will Often Backfire on You
Legacy signals
Legacy popularity: 1,334 legacy views
The most effective way to get someone to do something, especially children, it to model the desired behavior. Nobody likes to be lectured to or be constantly told what to do. Lecturing will quickly send children in the opposite direction.
Model healthy interactions with your spouse and other adults. Always speak lovingly and respectfully.
Save shouting for safety only.
To teach your children manners say it for them rather than asking them to use the "Magic Word". As you serve say, "Thank you Mama!" When your child demands service say, "May I have some juice please Papa?"
Or, try using non-verbal signals. Decide with your children what the hand signal will be when they have asked for service inappropriately. Use the hand signal, such as touching your lips with your index finger, every time they demand service.
Maria Montessori has shown us that modeling appropriate behavior is particularly critical during a child's first six year of life, because children enter the Absorbent Mind developmental phase. A child's mind acts like a sponge, integrating everything accurately, nonjudmentally, uncritically and effortlessly.
During the approximate ages of 2 1/5 to five years, children enter the Sensitive Period for Social Development phase. A child explores and absorbs group and social behavior. Due to this sensitivity, a child needs to have modeled acceptable social behavior at home and in a positive school setting.
The late guru, Rudolph Dreikurs, teaches us to teach and model mutual respect. Be kind and firm at the same time. Kind to show respect for your child, firm to show respect for yourself and the needs of the situation. This is difficult!
- Ask, Tell, Respond, Act:
- Ask first: "Please put your activity away." Back off and wait. If needed:
- Tell once: "This goes right here." Hand her the toy and pat the shelf.
- Respond: "OK Mama, I'm putting it away!." (Say if for her.) If needed:
- Act: "Let's do it together!" Do it with joy! (Even if she doesn't help.)
- Teach and model that mistakes are great opportunities to learn:
Clean up your messes:
1. Own your part: "Wow, I just made a mistake!"
2. Apologize: "I apologize for_____. (Be specific)"
3. Commit: "The next time I will do _____ instead."
4. Amends: "To make it up to you I will do _____ for/with you."
When you want to make your child do something you are in a power struggle. Say "Oops, I'm trying to get my way, I'm going to go do something to help myself feel better."
Children express what we repress. When your child acts up, look inside yourself first. Clean up your act, resolve your feelings, mend fences.
Article author
About the Author
Further reading
Further Reading
Article
Sassy Kids: How to Deal with a Mouthy Child
Are you tired of disrespectful talk from your kids? Do your children respond with eye-rolling and sarcasm to everything you say? Most—if not all—kids go through phases when they are sassy, mouthy, or disrespectful. As a parent, it’s hard to know when to let it slide—and when to address the problem. James Lehman explains where to draw the line—and tells you how you can manage sassy talk in your home.
Related piece
Article
Child Discipline: Consequences and Effective Parenting
Remember how you felt when you brought your baby home from the hospital for the first time? When your child was an infant, you probably acknowledged that you were anxious and unsure of what you were doing at times—most new parents are. In my experience, those kinds of feelings continue as we raise our kids—we just stop expressing them to others.
Related piece
Article
The Greatest Lesson In Life
When you are at peace with having a baby or not having a baby, then what will be, will be. You will either have one (as you were supposed to) or you will not have one (as it was not meant to be). Accept the fact that God has a plan for your life, which may not include children. If you don’t ...
Related piece
Article
Managing Parental Expectations
One of the most challenging aspects of being a mom is managing the expectations of yourself and others. Motherhood is a world of compromise, flexibility and negotiations. It’s a balancing act between doing what you want to do and doing what you have to do.
Related piece