Avoid *Be Spontaneous!* Paradoxes
Written by Peter K. Gerlach, MSW
Can you define a "paradox" to an average 12-year-old? Try saying your definition out loud, and compare it to this: "A *paradox* is something that inherently negates itself." Paradoxes exist because many things in the world have different levels of meaning, depending on the context. A simple example is - if you're (1) walking to the rear of a moving train or plane, you're also (2) moving forward (relative to the ground), and (3) spiralling around the sun as (4) the galaxy spins and (5) moves through space.
Notice how your mind reacts to the statement "I can move in five directions at once." Normal reactions to interpersonal paradoxes and double messages (like "I love you. Go away.") are confusion, and sometimes irritation and distrust.
A common class of paradoxes occurs with the normal human trait of *denials* - e.g. an addict swearing he or she does not use drugs or gamble compulsively, when the evidence says otherwise.
Knowledge of this curious reality is important in normal relationships, because without awareness of it, we're all vulnerable to a dynamic called a Be Spontaneous! paradox. The title says it all, for by definition - you can't demand that someone be spontaneous, because that can only come from within.
"BE SPONTANEOUS!" PARADOXES
This dynamic manifests among people who aren't unaware of it and of their needs and behavior, in many ways. Their behaviors usually cause frustration, confusion, disorientation and "stress" - specially if the initiator denies or rationalizes their paradoxic behavior. ("You MUST trust me, because...")
The paradox occurs because we all long for certain responses in important other people that can only be given spontaneously - like love, trust, respect, honesty, patience, commitment, appreciation, loyalty, compassion, interest, empathy, humor, desire, and tolerance.
For example, if your spouse says "You have to respect me because I'm your mate!" that sets up an impossible expectation - because genuine respect can only be earned. If the receiver says "OK" and tries to manifest respect out of duty, fear, and/or guilt, the initiator can complai
"You're only doing that because I asked you to, not because you *want* to." Things get even more confusing if the responder denies that.
The way out of this relationship snare is for people to (a) be aware of paradoxic expectations, and to (b) use win-win problem solving to get their mutual needs met. That might sound like person "A" saying "I need to feel more respected by you more often. Am I doing something that you don't respect?"
Person "B" says (if it's safe) "Yes. You're eating unhealthily, not exercising well, working too hard, sleeping too little, and ignoring your body. I have a hard time respecting you because your behavior says you don't respect yourself. I need you to
*want to* value yourself more - for *you,* not for me."
Notice the potential here for another Be Spontaneous!paradox: "B" could fruitlessly *demand* that "A" respect
herself more. Lose-lose.
If you accept this idea, then the next time someone doesn't meet your expectations, (or you don't meet theirs), check for a Be Spontaneous! paradox. Tell other important people about this dynamic, and help each other avoid them.
For more perspective, see the article on "30 Common Communication Blocks" (and what to do about them) at http://sfhelp.org/cx/blocks.htm
Article author
About the Author
Further reading
Further Reading
Article
How common is self-love, what happens without it, and how does it relate to self-esteem?
Self-love is very essential in boosting our self-esteem. A person having self-love is contented with his own presence, whereas a person who does not have self-love always wanders to get love from other people or things. He is always restless. He never feels satisfied even after receiving love from people. His hunger for love never ceases, and hence he demands more and more attention from others. As a result, his relationships are ruined and he always lives in misery.rn rnSo,
October 23, 2025
Article
Who is a True Guru? How to choose a Spiritual Guru?
Grave danger in uprooting a Guru Do not accept a known guru as guru, and if you do, then do not turn your back on him. Use a pot if you do not like him. The pot will not have any problems. Worship it because your buddhi (intellect) will not be active there and your work will get done. Now who would be so careful that he would not allow his intellect to interfere? How can one understand all this? Questioner: At the time we make someone our guru, he appears to be very good, he
September 4, 2025
Article
How can I balance material responsibilities with spiritual goals?
The spiritual science of Akram Vignan helps us find the balance between taking care of our material responsibilities and pursuing our spiritual goals, very easily, as this spiritual science works alongside our material obligations. In Akram Vignan, the fundamental change starts internally when the ignorance of the Self is completely removed through the grace of the Enlightened Being (Gnani Purush). Here, Self-Realisation is attained through a scientific process of Bhed-Vignan
August 29, 2025
Article
What is the importance of Living Guru?
Questioner: If we surrender to the great souls that lived thousands of years ago, can that be considered surrender? Can we make any progress through such surrender or do we need to surrender to a living great man? Dadashri: You can progress even through Paroksha (indirectly- one not currently living). However if you find such a living (Pratyaksh) person, then your liberation will be instant. The indirect approach will give you the benefit of progress but there is no liberatio
July 9, 2025